558 GAY ST — primary listing photo
    ActiveResidential· 25 days on market

    558 GAY ST

    Washington, VA

    List price

    $1,525,000

    558 GAY ST — featured photo
    558 GAY ST — photo 2
    558 GAY ST — photo 3
    558 GAY ST — photo 4
    558 GAY ST — photo 5
    558 GAY ST — photo 6
    558 GAY ST — photo 7

    30 listing photos · scroll down for the full gallery

    4

    Bedrooms

    Bathrooms

    3,062

    Square feet

    0.75

    Acres

    1890

    Year built

    About this property

    Welcome to the formally registered Dudley House at 558 Gay Street, a stunning 1890 late-Victorian estate nestled in the original town surveyed by a 17-year-old George Washington. Situated on land whose title traces back to a 1798 town grant, this architectural gem has just undergone a complete, uncompromising, top-to-bottom reconstruction. While the current owner meticulously preserved the home's 19th-century soul, the renovation brought the house up to modern standards of comfort and efficiency. This is a true down-to-the-studs rebirth, and the home now features entirely new electrical wiring, ductwork, plumbing, a new electric water heater, a state-of-the-art two-zone heat pump system, and an all-new metal standing seam roof. The technical integrity of the Dudley House is unparalleled in the historic market. The structure has been bolstered with new attic insulation and high-performance, aluminum-clad double-hung Marvin windows that offer modern thermal efficiency without sacrificing the home's iconic historic profile. The owner has even pre-installed the infrastructure for a backup generator. Inside, the craftsmanship is felt at every turn, from the beautifully restored original heart pine floors to the spectacular walnut centr

    Property details

    Type
    SingleFamilyResidence
    Style
    Victorian
    Subdivision
    Other
    County
    Rappahannock
    Stories
    2
    Fireplaces
    1
    Pool
    None
    Annual tax (2025)
    $4,222
    Interior
    Attic · Permanent Attic Stairs · Eat-in Kitchen · Kitchen Island
    Exterior
    Playground
    Cooling
    Heat Pump · Ceiling Fan(s)
    Heating
    Electric · Heat Pump
    View
    Garden · Mountain(s) · Panoramic · Trees/Woods · Water

    Schools

    Elementary
    Rappahannock
    Middle
    Other
    High
    Rappahannock (Rappahannock)

    Gallery (30 photos)

    558 GAY ST — photo 8
    558 GAY ST — photo 9
    558 GAY ST — photo 10
    558 GAY ST — photo 11
    558 GAY ST — photo 12
    558 GAY ST — photo 13
    558 GAY ST — photo 14
    558 GAY ST — photo 15
    558 GAY ST — photo 16
    558 GAY ST — photo 17
    558 GAY ST — photo 18
    558 GAY ST — photo 19
    558 GAY ST — photo 20
    558 GAY ST — photo 21
    558 GAY ST — photo 22
    558 GAY ST — photo 23
    558 GAY ST — photo 24
    558 GAY ST — photo 25
    558 GAY ST — photo 26
    558 GAY ST — photo 27
    558 GAY ST — photo 28
    558 GAY ST — photo 29
    558 GAY ST — photo 30

    Listing courtesy of: BrightMLS Office — Default Agent Bright

    MLS #241591637 · CAAR · Updated May 14, 2026

    This information is believed to be accurate, but without warranty.